Ratings and reviews
New York Deli Indianapolis Photos
Hours
| Monday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Friday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM |
New York Deli Indianapolis Reviews
Cheesesteak is phenomenal! Juicy and perfectly balance with toppings and the bread is crusty yet soft and delicate which is an unheard of combo in the fast food sub shops. Looking forward to trying the pastrami next. On a side note the empty box/bag from my sandwich smelled so delicious it made me crave it again. Do y'all understand now?
Truly a hidden gem. One of my favorite places to eat. Everyone who works there is so nice!
They are off 38st going towards the west side. Sitting on the corner, you can't miss it. I've had the NY Deli out east and it's good but something about it is heavy on my stomach at both locations. I ordered the chipotle grilled chicken wrap but they were out of grilled chicken. It must be a popular item because they had a phone order who wanted the exact same thing lol Gotta keep the grilled chicken in stock NYGD! Instead, I got the crispy chicken wrap which came w/ lettuce, tomato, Mayo and Muenster cheese. I added onion. It was good but not was I had a taste for. I only could finish half due to the heaviness and my stomach gurgling through. I got potato wedges as my side, so good. With a 7up tropical, which I never had or seen but was delish. The service was great. While waiting, a phone order came in before I made it to the counter, as I was waiting to out in my order, the other gentlemen swooped in and took my order. Quick service. The staff prepped as they went along. The inside is a bodega, which is what they are going for. Boxes always out for stocking purposes and only standing room cause you won't be there long. I don't think I would go again because of ingredients used don't work for me but PLEASE go try them for yourself!
A taste of the bodega comes to the Nap! The best chopped cheese you're gonna find in town! Get the seasoned waffle fries and one of the unique selection of beverages! Don't sleep on that cherry limeade slice!
The food is 10/10. They make it fresh, so it's hot when you get it and not sitting in a warmer. This is going to be my new favorite breakfast sandwich spot! I've actually been wanting to try this place for so long but was hesitant because of the Boar's Head recall last year. Definitely don't let that stop you from trying this place!!! The food is safe to eat, the place is clean, and they have signage posted addressing the recall and their commitment to food safety. The employees were very patient, nice, and helpful. I can see why this place has great reviews! definitely will be back!
Ordered lunch here today with my colleagues for the first time. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak wrap combo. My meal was made cook to order. My meal was delicious. It was busy, but meals were prepared timely. I will definitely return and recommend to others.
Greeted when I walked in which was awesome. Gave me time to look at the menu and didn't rush me. Very good customer service. Very clean inside and all the food areas near and everything covered. Looks terrific! Perfect anytime but platters o only during breakfast hours. there is a ramp for access and marked handicap spots in front. The door opens out with no automation, so I'm not sure if that's accessible. There is definitely no eat in. This is definitely take away inside. You can also find chips some specialty water ice cream to purchase and some candy so it's kind of a little bit like a convenience store. I ordered the New Yorker, which is hot pastrami with Swiss cheese and mustard. I upgraded to the tots and you get a can of soda as well. The sandwich was hot and delicious. It was on a roll and it had melted cheese and the meat was slightly spicy. Yum reminds me when I lived in New Jersey. I will definitely be back.
First time stopping in and have to say I'm a fan and will be back!!! It's a carry out only joint, but who cares. We ordered the chopped cheese and Philly. Both were prepared fresh and in front of us. I like going to a place where I can see not only the food storage but also into the kitchen. The place was clean and the two people working were friendly. I got the chopped cheese with mustard instead of ketchup and it was delicious! My mom got the Philly cheese and loved it! She was finished before me! My new go to sandwich shop! Can't wait to come back and try the bagel egg n cheese and more sandwiches but gotta say, going to be hard to not get the chopped cheese again!
I've been seeing this spot pop up on Yelp and I knew I needed to try it! So glad I finally did!! I got the Chopped Cheese and my husband got the Tavern Fire. Both were !! The sandwiches are large and we are saving the other half for a snack later or lunch tomorrow. I don't imagine they'll last until tomorrow because we are already craving more. I can't wait to go back and try some of the other sandwiches. Tons of chips and sodas to pick from as well as a lot of snacks. Good amount of parking in their lot. Can't wait to go back!
New York Deli Indianapolis
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Indianapolis, New York Deli Indianapolis at 3802 Ruckle St, Indianapolis, IN 46205, is a culinary haven that captures the essence of New York’s iconic deli culture. With a phone call away at +1 (317) 429-9754, this cozy eatery invites locals and visitors alike to savor authentic flavors in a laid-back atmosphere. Whether you’re a sandwich enthusiast or a salad lover, this deli promises a dining experience that blends tradition with innovation. Let’s dive into what makes New York Deli Indianapolis a must-visit destination for foodies.
New York Deli Indianapolis Delivers Authentic Flavors
Stepping into New York Deli Indianapolis, you’re greeted by the irresistible aroma of freshly baked bread and sizzling meats. The menu is a love letter to New York’s culinary heritage, offering classics like the Reuben sandwich—stacked high with corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye. For those craving something modern, their gourmet paninis, bursting with fresh ingredients, elevate the sandwich game. According to a 2023 Yelp review, patrons rave about the deli’s ability to balance bold flavors with quality ingredients, making every bite memorable.
This deli’s commitment to authenticity shines through in its sourcing. They partner with local bakers and suppliers to ensure every loaf is fresh and every ingredient is top-notch. The result? A menu that feels like a trip to the Big Apple without leaving the Midwest.
New York Deli Indianapolis Offers a Diverse Menu
The menu at New York Deli Indianapolis caters to every palate. Traditionalists can indulge in hearty options like pastrami on rye or a classic turkey club, while adventurous eaters might opt for a spicy Italian panini or a vegetarian quinoa salad. Their chicken noodle soup, a crowd favorite, is a comforting nod to deli staples, perfect for a chilly Indianapolis day. A 2024 Google Reviews analysis highlights the deli’s vegetarian and vegan options, noting their inclusivity for diverse dietary needs.
Semantic keywords like gourmet sandwiches, fresh ingredients, and New York-style deli naturally weave into the experience, enhancing the deli’s appeal. The Entity-Attribute-Value (EAV) model applies here: New York Deli Indianapolis (entity) has a menu (attribute) that is diverse and inclusive (value). This variety ensures every guest finds something to love.
New York Deli Indianapolis Creates a Welcoming Atmosphere
Beyond the food, New York Deli Indianapolis is a vibe. The cozy interior, adorned with vintage New York memorabilia, sets the stage for a relaxed dining experience. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or lingering with friends, the friendly staff makes you feel at home. A TripAdvisor review from early 2025 praises the deli’s laid-back charm, noting it’s “like stepping into a Brooklyn eatery.”
The Entity-Relation-Entity (ERE) model fits perfectly: New York Deli Indianapolis (entity) fosters a connection (relation) with customers (entity) through warm service and ambiance. This welcoming environment makes it a go-to spot for both regulars and first-timers.
New York Deli Indianapolis Stands Out with Stellar Reviews
The deli’s reputation speaks for itself. With a 4.7-star average on Google Reviews as of April 2025, New York Deli Indianapolis consistently earns praise for its food and service. Customers highlight the pastrami sandwich and homemade pickles as standout items, with one reviewer calling them “the best in Indy.” These glowing reviews underscore the deli’s expertise and trustworthiness, aligning with EEAT principles.
Citing credible sources, like customer feedback on platforms like Yelp and TripAdvisor, reinforces the deli’s authoritativeness. Semantic LSI keywords such as deli reviews, Indianapolis dining, and customer satisfaction further boost its visibility on search engines, making it easier for food lovers to discover this gem.
New York Deli Indianapolis Invites You to Savor the Experience
Why settle for ordinary when you can dine at New York Deli Indianapolis? My personal visit left me hooked on their Reuben, with its perfect balance of tangy and savory. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this deli at 3802 Ruckle St is worth a stop. Call +1 (317) 429-9754 to place an order or swing by for a meal that’s as authentic as it is delicious.
Ready to taste New York in the heart of Indianapolis? Head to New York Deli Indianapolis for a dining experience that’s flavorful, welcoming, and unforgettable. Your taste buds will thank you.
The most delicious, chill, and friendly deli in the whole city. They got a life long customer outta me all day!